How should management control the front end of innovation?

A study examined the use of management control in the front end of innovation, and how the different mechanisms of control are associated with generating strategic renewal. The foundation for successful new product development is created in the front end of innovation, which refers to the activities that take place before the formal product development project. The front end of innovation has been characterized as highly uncertain and creative, thereby requiring high levels of freedom and independence for those executing front-end activities. However, a certain amount of control appears necessary to secure the effective use of resources and the achievement of the company’s long-term objectives. So, how should management control the front end of innovation? Data from the front-end phase of 133 new product development projects from different large and medium-sized companies were collected and analyzed.

The results show that input control is positively associated with achieving strategic renewal in the front-end phase. The results also confirm the importance of intrinsic task motivation of the front-end group. But under high technology uncertainty as moderating factor, the use of outcome based rewarding or front-end process formalization has a negative influence on strategic renewal.

This study’s results include a significant managerial implication. Management can well use formalized process structures to run its front-end projects – if such a control approach is justified by other reasons (e.g., clarity), and it can use outcome-based rewarding if it is in line with the normal rewarding system without fear of negative influence on strategic renewal.



Poskela, J., Martinsuo, M., 2009. Management control and strategic renewal in the front end of innovation. The Journal of Product Innovation Management, 26 (6), 671-684.

Mer från InventiveBoard

Control systems under different innovation management modes

One study focused on the relationships between innovation and management accounting and control systems (MACS). This was done by emphasising the importance of the choice by which individual MACS are selected for interactive (as opposed to diagnostic) use. Using survey data collected from 57 medium-sized…

Läs mer

Success and failure of innovation

Why does not everybody innovate? It is widely recognized that innovation is key to the economic performance of firms. If nonetheless many firms do not dare to innovate, this has to do with several types of risks and uncertainties that lead to high failure rates. A review examined…

Läs mer